School Ethics Commission Decisions» NJ School Law Home

Decisions:

Search | Arbitrator TEACHNJ | Commissioner | State Board | School Ethics | Board of Examiners | Charter School Tenure | OAL

The following list is in chronological order. If you know the name of a particular case you are looking for, or of any party it involves, use the "Find" feature of the "Edit" menu to search the list.

The decisions are in Adobe PDF (version 3.0) format. You will need Adobe Acrobat Reader version 3.0 or higher to view them. Be sure to read the instructions that come with the reader carefully for information on viewing and printing documents.

Adobe Acrobat


SCHOOL ETHICS COMMISSION DECISIONS 2009

Young v. A.J. Kreimer, Moorestown Twp. Board of Education, Burlington County, C02-08, 1/27/09

Dericks et al. v. Schiavoni, Sparta Board of Education, Sussex County, C41-07;  Sharpe et al. v. Johnson et al., Sparta Board of Education, Sussex County, C46-07; and Dericks et al. v. Curcio et al., Sparta Board of Education, Sussex County, C47-07, (Consolidated) 2/24/09
» Commissioner’s Decision

In the Matter of David Hollander, Springfield Board of Education, Union County, C49-07, 2/24/09
» Commissioner’s Decision

I/M/O James Chiego, Union Township Bd. of Education, Hunterdon County, (On Remand) C51-05, 3/34/09

Hakim v. Paitchell, Clifton Board of Education, Passaic County C17-07; Paitchell v. Urciuoli et al. Clifton Board of Education, Passaic County, C17A-07, 3/24/09

Shinevar and Beslow v. Norian, Oradell Board of Education, Bergen County, C25-07, 3/24/09

Wittreich v. Jordan et al., Franklin Township Board of Education, Somerset County, C39-07, 3/24/09

Jenkins-Buwa v. Rivers et al., Plainfield Board of Education, C39-08, 3/24/09

Derricks et al. v. Schiavoni, Sparta Board of Education, Sussex County, C40-07; and
Dericks et al. v. Curcio et al., Sparta Board of Education, Sussex County, C45-07 (Consolidated), 4/28/09

» Commissioner’s Decision
                                                                                               
Myers v. Barksdale, et al., Plainfield Board of Education, Union County, C05-08, 4/28/09

LiaBraaten v. Emery, West Morris Regional Bd. of Education, Morris County, C14-08, 4/28/09

Lovett and Fussell v. Asbury et al., Freedom Academy Charter School Bd. of Trustees, Camden County, C01-09, 4/28/09

Myers v. Barksdale, Plainfield Board of Education, Union County, C04-08, 5/27/09

Myers v. Cox, Plainfield Board of Education, Union County, C06-08, 5/27/09

Le Munyon v. Loughlin, Cape May City Board of Education, Cape May County, C23-08, 5/27/09

Luthman v. Longo, Toms River Regional Bd. of Ed., Ocean County, C17-08, 6/23/09

Herrschaft v. Ciancaglini, Franklin Twp. Bd. of Ed., Gloucester County, C18-08, 7/28/09

Armenti v. Reca, Robbinsville Bd. of Ed., Mercer County, C07-09, 7/28/09

Saxton v. Belsky, Ramapo-Indian Hills Board of Ed., Bergen County, C35-08, 9/22/09

Dericks et al. v. Johnson et al., Sparta Board of Education, Sussex County, C01-08, 10/27/09

John et al. v. Gordon, Willingboro Board of Education, Burlington County, C34-08, 10/27/09
» Commissioner decision

I/M/O RaShun Stewart, Oceanside Charter School, Atlantic County, C17-09, 10/27/09
» Commissioner Decision

I/M/O Jose Ybarra, Passaic City Board of Education, Passaic County, C20-09, 10/27/09
» Commissioner Decision

Mott v. McDonnell, Green Township Board of Education, Sussex County, C21-09, 10/27/09

Mott v. Cooke, Green Township Board of Education, Sussex County, C22-09, 10/27/09

Valdes v. Caputo, Union City Bd. of Education, Hudson County, C22-08, 11/24/09

Rosenwald v. Lawson, Freehold Regional H.S. District Bd. of Ed., Monmouth County, C32-09, 11/24/09

Chamberlin v. Bencivengo et al., Hamilton Bd. of Ed., Mercer County, C35-09, 11/24/09

Rogers v. Somjen, Roxbury Bd. of Ed., Morris County, C37-08, 12/15/09

Bouyer v. Owens and McCoy, Willingboro Bd. of Ed., Burlington County, C37-09, 12/15/09

Bouyer v. Walker, Willingboro Bd. of Ed., Burlington County, C38-09, 12/15/09

Spearman v. Lassiter, Irvington Bd. of Ed., Essex County, C24-08, 12/15/09

Taylor v. Mitchell, Barnegat Bd. of Ed., Ocean County, C27-08, 12/15/09

SCHOOL ETHICS COMMISSION DECISIONS 2010

Kazmark v. Depsee, West Paterson Bd. of Ed., Hasko, Passaic Valley High School Bd. of Ed. & Fazio, West Paterson Bd. of Ed., Passaic County, C38-08, 1/26/10

I/M/O William Depsee, Woodland Park Bd. of Ed., Passaic County, C30-09, 1/26/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

Johnson and Schill v. Pollison, Sparta Bd. of Ed., Sussex County, C39-09, 1/26/10

Bouyer v. John and Walker, Willingboro Bd. of Ed., Burlington County, C36-08, 2/23/10

Mott v. Frederiks, Allamuchy Board of Education, Allamuchy Bd. of Ed., Warren County, C23-09, 2/23/10

Spencer v. Wilson, Camden Bd. of Education, Camden County, C41-09, 2/23/10

I/M/O Charles Carey, Pennsauken Bd. of Ed., Camden County, C33-08, 3/23/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

Kuchta et al. v. Casale, Nutley Bd. of Ed., Essex County, C02-09, C04-09, C05-09, C06-09 Consolidated, 3/23/10

Ferguson v. Fipp et al., Northfield Bd. of Ed., Atlantic County, C12-09, 3/23/10

McGivney v. Zarish, Flemington-Raritan Regional Bd. of Ed., Hunterdon County, C31-09, 3/23/10

Worrell v. Minniti, Greenwich Bd. of Ed., Gloucester County, C45-09, 3/23/10

I/M/O Brown and Garrison, Englewood Board of Education, Bergen County, C26-08, 4/20/10

I/M/O Guarascio, Berkeley Township Board of Education, Ocean County, C40-08, 4/20/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

I/M/O Jordan, High Bridge Board of Education, Hunterdon County, C03-09, 4/20/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

Brister v. Tanner, Roselle Borough Board of Education, Union County, C09-09, 4/20/10

I/M/O Carey, Pennsauken Board of Education, Camden County, C27-09, 4/20/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

I/M/O Frank Minniti, Greenwich Twp. Bd. of Education, Gloucester County, C08-09, 5/25/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

Dagastino v. Bennett, Fairfield Bd. of Education, Cumberland County, C19-09, 5/25/10

Alma v. Fajardo and Munoz, Elizabeth Bd. of Ed., Union County, C07-07, 6/22/10

Demarest et al. v. Pantoja and Makino, Prospect Park Bd. of Ed., Passaic County, C08-10, 6/22/10

Ellen Ogintz v. Robert Laverty, East Windsor Regional Bd. of Ed., Mercer County, C29-09, 7/27/10

Gryskiewicz v. Sproviero, Elmwood Park Board of Education, Bergen County, C15-10, 8/31/10

I/M/O Jan Rubino, Matawan Aberdeen Board of Ed., Monmouth County, C16-08, 9/28/10
» OAL Decision
» Commissioner’s Decision:

Longo v. Schwartz, Belleville Board of Ed., Essex County, C01-10, 9/28/10

J.E.T., Jr. & J.L.T. v. Stonis et. al., Cumberland Regional Bd. of Ed., C09-10, 9/28/10

Southerland v. Vauss, Irvington Bd. of Ed., Essex County, C17-10, 9/28/10

Digesere v. Campbell, Kearny Board of Education, Hudson County, C02-10, 10/26/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

I/M/O Paul Birch, Prospect Park Board of Education, Passaic County, C04-10, 10/26/10
» Commissioner’s Decision

Merola v. Schaible, Monmouth Regional High School Board of Education, C22-10, 10/26/10

Valdes v. Sanger, Union City Board of Education, C24-10, 10/26/10

I/M/O J. Garfield Jackson, East Orange Board of Education, Essex County, C37-07, 12/21/10
» OAL Decision
» Commissioner’s Decision

SCHOOL ETHICS COMMISSION DECISIONS 2011

Danis v. Milevski, Garfield Board of Education, Bergen County, C30-10, 1/25/11

Danis v. Milevski, Garfield Board of Education, Bergen County, C36-10, 1/25/11

Danis v. Koch, Garfield Board of Education, Bergen County, C37-10, 1/25/11

S.L.G. and M.S., as parents of D.S. and D.S. v. Granata et. al., Livingston Bd. of Ed., Essex County, C18-10, 2/22/11
» Commissioner’s Decision

Valdes v. Morejon, Union City Bd. of Ed., Hudson County, C39-10, 2/22/11

DaPonte v. Becker & Skully, Barnegat Bd. of Ed., Ocean County, C42-10, 2/22/11

K.S.M. v. Chris Haley, Manasquan Board of Education, Monmouth County, C27-10, 3/22/11

Kliszus v. Williams-Bembry, Hackensack Board of Education, Bergen County, C45-10, 3/22/11

Oramas-Shirey v. Gallo, et. al. Bethlehem Township Board of Education, Hunterdon County, C43-10, 3/22/11

Simon v. Storcella and Doyle, Margate Board of Education, Atlantic County, C49-10, 3/22/11

Foody v. Bailey et al., West Milford Township Board of Education, Passaic County, C07-11, 5/24/11

Fanelli v. Terebush, Brick Township Board of Education, Ocean County, C08-11, 5/24/11

Ferrara v. Hewitson, Hamilton Twp. Bd. of Ed., Mercer County, C01-11, 6/28/11

Campbell v. McDonald, Kearny Bd. of Ed., Hudson County, C05-11, 6/28/11

Campbell v. Santos, Kearny Bd. of Ed., Hudson County, C06-11, 6/28/11

Smith v. Granata et al. Livingston Bd. of Education, Essex County, C46-10, 7/26/11

Hoh v. C.B., Mine Hill Board of Education, Morris County, C50-10, 7/26/11

Tashjian v. Hartman, River Dell Regional Bd. of Education, Bergen County, C03-11, 7/26/11

Pellecchia v. Riley & Parks, Berkeley Twp. Bd. of Ed., Ocean County, C15-11, 7/26/11

Kliszus v. Williams Bembry, Hackensack Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C29-10, 8/23/11

Viggiano v. Shelan, Florence Bd. of Ed. , Burlington County, C32-10, 8/23/11

Yoon v. Bandlow, Fort Lee Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C18-11, 8/23/11

Yoon v. Engravalle, Fort Lee Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C19-11, 8/23/11

Yoon v. Balletto, Fort Lee Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C20-11, 8/23/11

Yoon v. Lupino, Fort Lee Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C21-11, 8/23/11

Yoon v. Suh, Fort Lee Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C22-11, 8/23/11

Yoon v. Stux-Ramirez, Fort Lee Bd. of Ed., Bergen County, C23-11, 8/23/11

G.M.B. v. Zirkle, Cumberland Regional Bd. of Ed., Cumberland Co., C44-10 (9/27/11)
» Commissioner’s Decision

I/M/O Pellecchia, Berkeley Twp., Ocean Co. , C48-10 (9/27/11)

Pitts v. Gidwani, Winslow Twp. BOE, Camden Co., C27-11 (9/27/11)

Kliszus v. Gilliam Gardner, Hackensack Board of Education, Bergen County, C28-10 & C34-10 (Consolidated), 10/25/11

Campbell v. Stevenson, Kearny Board of Education, Hudson County, C04-11, 10/25/11
» Commissioner’s Decision

Toorzani v. Tomko et al., Elmwood Park Board of Education, Bergen County, C29-11, 10/25/11

Wallace & West v. Albolino, et al., Hackensack Board of Ed., Bergen County, C33-10, 11/22/11

Bey v. Brown, Camden City Board of Education, Camden County, C25-11, 12/20/11
» Commissioner’s Decision

Silva v. Seitler, Lakewood Board of Education, Ocean County, C10-11, 12/20/11

SCHOOL ETHICS COMMISSION DECISIONS 2012

Silva v. Silver, Lakewood Board of Education, Ocean County, C09-11, 1/24/12

Dagostino v. Kennedy, Fairfield Board of Education, Cumberland County, C17-11, 1/24/12

Persi v. Woska, Brick Township Board of Ed., Ocean County, C25-08, 2/28/12

I/M/O Sanford Student, Evesham Township Board of Ed., Burlington County, C40-09, 2/28/12

Dimon v. Skinner, Florence Township Board of Ed., Burlington County, C11-10, 2/28/12

I/M/O Joseph Raines, Asbury Park Board of Ed., Monmouth County, C36-11, 2/28/12

Frascella v. Tola & DelGiudice, Hamilton Township Board of Ed., Mercer County, C42-11, 2/28/12

Vellon v. Longo et al., Belleville Bd. of Education, Essex County, C43-11, 3/27/12

Fisher v. Hamilton, Hamilton Twp. Bd. of Education, Mercer County, C50-11, 3/27/12

Cureton et al. v. Albolino et al., Hackensack Bd. of Education, Bergen County, C52-11, 3/27/12

Fisher v. Tola et al., Hamilton Township Board of Education, Mercer County, C57-11 (4/24/12)

Kern v. Wynne, Northfield Board of Education, Atlantic County, C47-11, 5/29/12

Bleistine v. Cunningham, South Harrison Twp. Board of Education, Gloucester County, C49-11, 5/29/12

Hewitson v.  DelGiudice, Hamilton Twp. Board of Ed., Mercer County, C28-11, 6/26/12

Martinez v. Albolino et al., Hackensack Board of Ed., Bergen County, C45-11, 6/26/12

Fisher v. Tola, Hamilton Twp. Board of Ed., Mercer County, C51-11, 6/26/12

Demiris v. Lent et al., Northern Valley Regional Board of Ed., Bergen County, C11-12, 6/26/12

AIELLO v. GOTTLIEB, West Milford Board of Education, Passaic County, C26-10, 08/28/12

Close v. Panzini, et al., Spring Lake Board of Education, Monmouth County, C22-12, 9/25/12

Bleistine v. McShea, South Harrison Twp. Board of Education, Gloucester County, C48-11, 12/18/12

Clark v. Hansen, Spring Lake Board of Education, Monmouth County, C32-12, 12/18/12

SCHOOL ETHICS COMMISSION DECISIONS 2013

Goldstein v. Lent, et al., Northern Valley Regional High School Board of Education, Bergen County, C37-12, 01/22/13

Caffrey v. Rodriquez, Perth Amboy Board of Education, Middlesex County, C47-12, 03/19/13

Chmielewski v. Fracasso, Hackettstown Board of Education, Warren County, C26-11, 3/19/13

Galante v. Brill, et al., West Orange Board of Education, Essex County, C07-12, 05/28/13

Baumgartner v. Castelli, Kearny Board of Education, Hudson County, C54-12, 05/28/13

Baumgartner v. King, Kearny Board of Education, Hudson County, C55-12, 05/28/13

Baumgartner v. Leadbeater, Kearny Board of Education, Hudson County, C56-12, 05/28/13

Baumgartner v. Plaugic, Kearny Board of Education, Hudson County, C57-12, 05/28/13

Spadafora v. Radio, Clayton Board of Education,  Gloucester County, C03-13, 06/25/13

Pilovsky v. Caputo, Barnegat Twp. Board of Education, Ocean County, C08-13, 06/25/13

DiNapoli v. Quattrocchi, Verona Board of Education,  Essex County, C09-13, 06/25/13

Murphy v. Murphy, Washington Twp. Board of Education, Gloucester County, C44-11, 06/25/13

McClellan v.Bey-Blocker & Famularo, Pleasantville Board of Education, Atlantic County C05-12 & C06-12, 06/25/13

Caffrey v. Tejeda, Perth Amboy Board of Education, Middlesex County, C26-12, 07/30/13

Caffrey v. Lebreault, Perth Amboy Board of Education, Middlesex County, C27-12, 07/30/13

Caffrey v. Puccio, Perth Amboy Board of Education, Middlesex County, C28-12, 07/30/13

Caffrey v. Gonzalez, Perth Amboy Board of Education, Middlesex County, C29-12, 07/30/13

Berglund v. Gray, Deptford Twp. Board of Education, Gloucester Counter,  C10-13, 07/30/13

Close v. Messinger, Freehold Reg. H. S. District Board of Education, Monmouth County,  C14-13, 07/30/13

IMO Doris Graves, Pleasantville Board of Education, Atlantic County, C40-10, 07/30/13

Lesinski v. Hall, Smallwood & Taylor, Asbury Park Board of Education, Monmouth County, C27-13, 09/24/13

IMO Jerome Dunne and Alberto Marsal, Elizabeth Board of Education, Union County, C35-11, 09/24/13 (OAL Dkt.No. 14401-11)

Wilson v. Gray, Deptford Township Board of Education, Gloucester County, C17-13, 11/26/13

Messner&Condo v. Gray, Deptford Twp. Board of Education, Gloucester County, C16-13, 12/19/13 and
Berglund v. Gray, Deptford Twp. Board of Education, Gloucester County,  C22-13, 12/19/13 (Consolidated)

Pollack v. Dean, Marlboro Twp. Board of Education, Monmouth County, C20-13, 12/19/13

SCHOOL ETHICS COMMISSION DECISIONS 2014

I/M/O Sterling Waterman, Jersey City Board of Education, Hudson County, C10-12, EEC 03641-12, 01/28/14

Boyle  v. Giannakis, South Plainfield Board of Education, Middlesex County, C01-13, 01/28/14

IMO Brenda C. Moiso, Ocean City Board of Education, Cape May County, C03-12, May 27, 2014 (See OAL Docket No. 16381-12)

Molica v. Sayre, Pequannock Twp. Board of Education, Morris County, C07-13, 06/24/14  (OAL Dkt. No. EEC 11703-13)

Green v. Conlon, West Milford Board of Education, Passaic County, C21-13, 06/24/14

IMO AnthonyMontiero, Jr., Elizabeth Board of Education, Union County,  C26-13, 06/24/14