Textbook Evaluation Tool*
Return to Textbook Main Page







Reviewer's Name:____________________________________  School:______________________

Part 1: General Information
Title: Copyright date:
Author(s): Cost (student edition):
Publisher(s): Subject/Grade level:

Part 2: Organization/Format
Organizational feature
3
fully evident
2
mostly evident
1
partially evident
0
little or no evidence
Overall rating
Textbook provides a useful table of contents, glossary & index . . . . .
Layout is consistent and chapters are arranged logically . . . . .
Chapters contain clear and comprehensive introductions and summaries . . . . .
Textbook contains references, bibliography and resources . . . . .
Information is accurate & current . . . . .
Reading level is appropriate for age/grade . . . . .
Size and format of print is appropriate  . . . . .
Format is visually appealing & interesting . . . . .
Other (please specify) . . . . .
Total:
.

Part 3: Content
Content criteria
3
fully evident 
2
mostly evident
1
partially evident
0
little or no evidence
Overall rating
Real-life applications are given . . . . .
Information and directions are clearly written and explained . . . . .
Activities are developmentally appropriate . . . . .
Non text content (maps, graphs, pictures) are accurate and well integrated into the text . . . . .
Lessons/activities are interdisciplinary . . . . .
Activities apply to a diversity of student abilities, interests and learning styles . . . . .
Activities include guiding questions which encourage the development of higher-level thinking skills . . . . .
Other (please specify) . . . . .
Total:
.
Notes:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Part 4: Teacher's Edition/Supplementary Materials
Criteria
3
fully evident
2
mostly evident
1
partially evident
0
little or no evidence
Overall rating
Textbook provides a separate teacher's edition with resource package . . . . .
Teacher's edition is comprehensive, organized and easy to use . . . . .
References are readily available to the specific NJCCCS and skills addressed in each activity . . . . .
Supplementary materials listed below are well organized, of high quality, and are useful in enhancing instruction (rate all that apply:) . . . . .
Transparencies . . . . .
Manipulatives . . . . .
Prepared Kits . . . . .
Student practice/workbook . . . . .
Assessment materials . . . . .
Videos . . . . .
Software (CD-Roms, DVDs, Laserdiscs, etc.) . . . . .
Other (please specify) . . . . .
Total:
.
Notes:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Part 5: Inclusion/Equity/Diversity Issues
Criteria
3
fully evident
2
mostly evident
1
partially evident
0
little or no evidence
Overall rating
Women and minorities are featured in important roles  . . . . .
Subject matter covers a spectrum of accomplishments and contributions by all sexes, races and physical conditions . . . . .
All groups are presented in broad scope . . . . .
Pronouns and descriptors of both sexes are used equally . . . . .
Nouns, adjectives, terms and illustations are non-stereotypical and non-prejudicial . . . . .
Children of both sexes and various cultures and physical conditions will use the materials without feeling excluded, estranged or diminished . . . . .
References and timelines feature events throughout various parts of the world . . . . .
Other (please specify) . . . . .
Total:
.
Notes:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Part 6: Alignment with District Curriculum, State standards, skills and assessments
Criteria
3
fully evident
2
mostly evident
1
partially evident
0
little or no evidence
Overall rating
Textbook content aligns to distict curriculum.
Please specify:
 
 
 

 

. . . . .
Textbook content correlates to the New Jersey Core Curriculum Content Standards.
Please document specific details below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Textbook content correlates to the New Jersey Cross-Content Workplace Readiness Standards.
Please document specific details below:
 
 
 
 
 

 

. . . . .
Activities and assessments support student achievement of the Cumulative Progress Indicators (CPI's) in the major content area.
Please document below:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Activities and assessments support student achievement of the Cumulative Progress Indicators (CPI's) in the area of Cross-content Workplace Readiness
 
 
 
 

 

. . . . .
This textbook will be a useful resource in preparing students to meet the requirements of the NJ state standards and statewide assessments.
Please specify:
 
 
 
 
 

 

. . . . .
Total:
.

*The following resources were instrumental in the development of this tool:
Textbook Evaluation Form - Matanuska-Susitna Borough School District, Alaska
Some Points to Ponder in Textbook Evaluation - Rohrbach Library, Kutztown University, Kutztown, PA

Please email your suggestions and contributions for modifications to: NJPEP@doe.state.nj.us